Meta's Ad Systems Reportedly Generated Billions From Scam and Fraudulent Content
Leaked internal documents reportedly show Meta's advertising systems generated billions of dollars from scam ads, with the company aware that its personalization engine amplified fraud by showing interested users more scams, and that Chinese advertisers were a major source of this problematic revenue.
What happened
Leaked internal documents revealed that Meta estimated roughly 10 percent of its 2024 ad revenue, approximately $16 billion, came from ads violating its policies, including fraudulent e-commerce schemes, illegal online casinos, deceptive investment promotions and banned medical products.
Meta's internal reports indicated users were served an estimated 15 billion 'higher-risk' ads daily, with Meta's systems generating about $7 billion annually from ads linked to potentially fraudulent activity.
Meta's ad personalization engine amplified fraud by interpreting user clicks on scam ads as interest signals and showing users more of the same content, turning victims into targets for further fraud.
Meta calculated that approximately 19 percent of its over $18 billion in 2024 Chinese advertising revenue—more than $3 billion—came from ads for scams, illegal gambling, pornography and other banned content, with China representing roughly a quarter of all ads for scams and banned products on Meta's platforms worldwide.
Reported impact
Victims included shoppers in Taiwan who purchased bogus health supplements and investors in the United States and Canada who were swindled out of their savings through fake cryptocurrency schemes and fraudulent shopping sites.
Meta's 'High Value Accounts'—big-spending advertisers—were allowed to run ads despite repeated rule violations, accumulating hundreds of 'strikes' without being shut down, with more heavily spending advertisers receiving greater leniency.
Index analysis
Meta created an anti-fraud team that reduced problematic ads from China from 19 percent to 9 percent of total advertising revenue from that region during the second half of 2024.
Meta disbanded its China-focused anti-scam team following CEO Mark Zuckerberg's input regarding an 'Integrity Strategy pivot' in late 2024, and lifted a freeze on granting new Chinese ad agencies platform access.
Governance controls
Meta rejected the conclusions drawn from the leaked documents, calling revenue estimates 'rough' and 'overly inclusive,' while noting that user reports of scam ads have dropped by more than half over the past year.
Meta stated it is investing in detection tools, human moderation and AI controls, though it did not dispute the authenticity of the documents or the scale of the problem outlined.
Classification
Sources and evidence
Sources not yet published
This record was researched and written by the Index from original reporting. Its sources are still being verified by an editor, and they are listed here once that check is complete. Until then the record carries no reviewer.