Algorithm Recommendation Regulations
China · Regulation · Cyberspace Administration of China, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, Ministry of Public Security, State Administration for Market Regulation
Our summary
This regulation governs content recommendation algorithms used in internet information services in China. It applies to entities using algorithmic techniques to deliver personalised, synthesised, ranked, filtered or scheduled information to users. The rules establish content standards, user protection measures, platform responsibilities for managing algorithm safety and information security, and oversight mechanisms through registration and safety assessments.
Written by the Index in our own words. It is not legal advice; the official text is the authority.
Inside this policy
Every section of this policy in order. Our notes summarise each one in plain language and do not quote the official text, which is the authority.
Drafted by the Index An automated summary of the official text, not yet reviewed by a person.Reviewed Checked by a person against the official text.
41 sections
Jump to a chapter
第一章 General Provisions
5 sections
This chapter contains foundational provisions governing the regulation of recommendation algorithms in internet information services, covering the scope, responsible agencies, principles, and industry role.
第一条 Legislative basis and scope
Establishes the regulation's purpose: governing recommendation algorithm activities in online information services to protect national security, public interest, and individual rights while promoting healthy development of internet services. The regulation applies within China's territory.
第二条 Applicable technology definition
Defines recommendation algorithm technology as using synthetic generation, personalized delivery, ranking and filtering, search filtering, or scheduling and decision-making algorithms to deliver information to users.
第三条 Regulatory authority
National and local internet administration departments coordinate governance and oversight of recommendation services. Other relevant departments at national and local levels supervise these services according to their respective responsibilities.
第四条 Service provision principles
Providers of recommendation services must comply with laws and regulations, respect social ethics, uphold business and professional integrity, and adhere to principles of fairness, transparency, rationality, and good faith.
第五条 Industry self-regulation
Encourages industry organizations to establish and strengthen industry standards, norms, and self-disciplinary mechanisms that direct and guide service providers to develop standards, comply with requirements, and accept social oversight.
第二章 Information Service Standards
10 sections
This chapter establishes detailed requirements for how providers must operate recommendation services, covering value orientation, content standards, mechanism design, information audit, data handling, and user protection.
第六条 Content and harm prevention
Providers must maintain mainstream values and prevent harmful content. They are prohibited from using recommendation services for activities that endanger national security, public interest, or legal rights, and must prevent dissemination of prohibited information and harmful content.
第七条 Management systems and controls
Providers must establish responsibility for algorithm safety and implement systems and measures including algorithm review, ethics assessment, user registration, content audit, data and privacy protection, fraud prevention, security monitoring, and incident response. They must disclose service rules and maintain adequate personnel.
第八条 Algorithm evaluation and verification
Providers must regularly audit, evaluate, and verify their algorithms, models, data, and results. They are prohibited from deploying algorithms that induce user addiction, excessive consumption, or behavior that violates laws or ethical standards.
第九条 Information security and harmful content handling
Algorithm recommendation service providers must strengthen information security, establish a system to detect illegal and harmful content, and apply clear labeling to machine-generated synthetic information before distributing it. Providers must immediately stop transmitting illegal information and report it to regulatory authorities.
第十条 User model and tag management
Algorithm recommendation service providers must manage user profiles and tags properly, ensuring they do not record keywords related to illegal or harmful content as user interests or tags that would be used for content distribution.
第十一条 Feed page ecology management
Algorithm recommendation service providers must manage the layout and presentation of their platforms, establish human oversight and user choice mechanisms, and actively display mainstream-value-aligned information at key locations such as homepages and popular trends.
第十二条 Transparency and user protection measures
Algorithm recommendation service providers are encouraged to apply content deduplication and distribution strategies while improving the clarity and explainability of their filtering and ranking rules, to prevent harm and reduce disputes.
第十三条 Internet news information services
Providers offering news services through algorithm recommendations must obtain proper licenses, follow legal standards for news collection and distribution, and must not generate false news or distribute news from unauthorized sources.
第十四条 Prohibited algorithmic manipulation practices
Algorithm recommendation service providers are prohibited from using algorithms to falsely register accounts, manipulate user engagement, block information, manipulate rankings or search results, control trending topics, or interfere with information presentation in ways that affect public opinion or evade oversight.
第十五条 Prohibition on anticompetitive behavior
Algorithm recommendation service providers must not use algorithms to unreasonably restrict other internet service providers or disrupt their normal operations, and must not engage in monopolistic or unfair competition practices.
第三章 User rights protection
7 sections
This chapter establishes protections for user rights in algorithm recommendation services, covering disclosure obligations, user choice options, and accountability mechanisms that apply to algorithm recommendation service providers.
第十六条 Transparency disclosure requirements
Algorithm recommendation service providers must clearly inform users that they use algorithmic recommendations and must publicly disclose the basic principles, purposes, and main operational mechanisms of their algorithms.
第十七条 User choice and control options
Algorithm recommendation service providers must offer users a non-personalized option or an easy way to disable algorithmic recommendations, and must immediately stop providing the service when users choose to disable it. Providers must also allow users to view and delete their personal profile tags, and must explain and be responsible when algorithms significantly affect user rights.
第十八条 Services for minors
Providers of algorithmic recommendation services must fulfill legal obligations to protect minors online, develop age-appropriate modes, and curate information beneficial to their physical and mental wellbeing. They must not push content that could prompt unsafe behavior, violate social norms, induce harmful habits, or lead to internet addiction among minors.
第十九条 Services for elderly users
Providers of algorithmic recommendation services must safeguard the legitimate rights of older adults by considering their needs in transportation, healthcare, consumption and administrative matters, offering elderly-adapted intelligent services according to national standards, and monitoring and handling telecommunications fraud information to enable safe use.
第二十条 Work scheduling services
Providers offering work dispatch through algorithmic recommendations must protect workers' entitlements to compensation, rest and leave by creating sound algorithms governing order allocation, payment composition and timing, working hours, and reward or penalty mechanisms.
第二十一条 Consumer protection in sales
Providers offering goods or services to consumers through algorithmic recommendations must protect the right to fair dealing and must not use algorithms to apply discriminatory pricing or other unreasonable transaction conditions based on consumer preferences or purchase history.
第二十二条 User complaints and grievances
Providers of algorithmic recommendation services must establish simple and effective channels for user complaints and public complaints or reports, specify processing procedures and response timeframes, and promptly handle and report results back to users.
第四章 Supervision and management
8 sections
This chapter sets out rules for government oversight and regulation of algorithmic recommendation services, including their classification and tiered management, registration and documentation requirements, and compliance monitoring.
第二十三条 Tiered classification system
Relevant government departments shall establish a graded and categorized safety management framework for algorithmic recommendations based on the service's potential to influence public opinion or mobilize society, content types, user scale, data sensitivity, and degree of intervention in user behavior.
第二十四条 Registration requirements
Providers with algorithmic services having public influence or social mobilization capacity must register within ten working days, submitting information including provider name, service type, application domain, algorithm type, self-assessment reports and proposed public disclosures through an official system. They must update registrations within ten working days of changes and file for deregistration within twenty working days of service termination.
第二十五条 Registration approval
Relevant government departments shall review complete registration materials and issue approval with a registration number within thirty working days, or inform the applicant of rejection with reasons within that timeframe.
第二十六条 Public disclosure of registration
Providers that complete registration must clearly display their registration number on their websites, applications and other service platforms and provide links to the public information about their registration.
第二十七条 Safety assessment requirement
Providers of algorithmic recommendation services with news attributes or social mobilization capacity must conduct safety evaluations according to national regulations.
第二十八条 Regulatory oversight and compliance
Cyberspace authorities and related departments conduct safety evaluations and inspections of algorithmic services, issue correction notices with deadlines, and require providers to retain network logs and cooperate by providing technical and data support.
第二十九条 Confidentiality of personal and commercial information
Personnel involved in safety assessments and inspections must keep confidential any personal privacy, personal information, and business secrets they learn about during their work and must not disclose them.
第三十条 Public complaint and reporting mechanism
Any organization or individual may report violations of this regulation to cyberspace authorities and relevant departments, which must promptly handle such reports according to law.
第五章 Legal liability
3 sections
This chapter sets forth the legal consequences for violations of the regulation, covering three types of violations with corresponding penalties.
第三十一条 Penalties for major violations
Providers violating specified sections face warnings, public criticism, orders to correct within deadlines, and fines of 10,000 to 100,000 yuan if they refuse to comply or the violation is serious; applicable criminal or administrative penalties also apply.
第三十二条 Penalties for other violations
Providers violating other specified sections face administrative penalties determined by relevant authorities according to applicable laws, regulations, and departmental rules.
第三十三条 Penalties for fraudulent registration and termination violations
Providers with news or social mobilization attributes that fraudulently obtain registration face deregistration, warnings, and fines up to 100,000 yuan; providers that fail to properly deregister or face closure orders may have their registration revoked by cyberspace authorities.
第六章 Supplementary provisions
2 sections
This chapter contains final provisions including interpretation authority and effective date information.
第三十四条 Interpretation authority
The Cyberspace Administration together with industrial, information technology, public security, and market supervision departments is responsible for explaining this regulation.
第三十五条 Effective date
The regulation enters into force on March 1, 2022.
Controls
What this policy requires, forbids, grants or penalises, one control at a time and in our own words. Each control links to the official text, which is the authority. This is not legal advice.
Drafted by the Index Drafted automatically from the official text, not yet reviewed by a person.Reviewed Checked by a person against the official text.
Themes covered 21 of 35
Choose a theme to see only its controls. About the themes
Risk and scope 3 of 4
- Impact assessment, not covered
Data and privacy 2 of 4
- Cross-border data transfer, not covered
- Copyright and training data, not covered
Transparency and records 4 of 4
Technical safeguards 4 of 4
Assurance and lifecycle 2 of 4
- Conformity assessment and certification, not covered
- Post-market monitoring and corrective action, not covered
Rights and protected groups 2 of 4
- Automated decision-making rights, not covered
- Biometric identification and surveillance, not covered
Roles and organisation 2 of 6
- Supply chain and provider-deployer duties, not covered
- General purpose and foundation models, not covered
- Public sector use and procurement, not covered
- Innovation support and sandboxes, not covered
Enforcement and sectors 2 of 5
- Sector rules: health, not covered
- Sector rules: finance and insurance, not covered
- Sector rules: education, not covered
The full list of controls could not be loaded, so only the first 40 are shown.
第三条 4 controls
- ObligationApplies to: Public authorityDrafted by the Index
The national internet regulator must coordinate and oversee recommendation service governance and supervision across the country.
第三条 - ObligationApplies to: Public authorityDrafted by the Index
National-level telecommunications, public security and market supervision departments must supervise recommendation services according to their respective duties.
第三条 - ObligationApplies to: Public authorityDrafted by the Index
Local internet regulators must coordinate and oversee recommendation service governance within their region.
第三条 - ObligationApplies to: Public authorityDrafted by the Index
Local telecommunications, public security and market supervision departments must supervise recommendation services in their region according to their respective duties.
第三条
第四条 4 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must comply with all applicable laws and regulations.
第四条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must respect social ethics and morality in their operations.
第四条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must uphold business and professional integrity and ethics.
第四条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must follow principles of fairness, equity, transparency, scientific rationality and good faith.
第四条
第五条 1 control
- ObligationApplies to: OthersDrafted by the Index
Industry organizations should establish and strengthen industry standards, norms, and self-disciplinary mechanisms to direct algorithm service providers to develop standards, comply with requirements, and accept social oversight.
第五条
第六条 4 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must maintain mainstream values and optimize recommendation mechanisms to actively promote positive content.
第六条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use recommendation services to conduct activities that endanger national security, public interest, legal rights, or violate laws and administrative regulations.
第六条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use recommendation services to spread information prohibited by law or administrative regulation.
第六条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must take measures to prevent and resist the spread of harmful information.
第六条
第七条 3 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must implement responsibility for algorithm safety and establish systems and measures for algorithm review, ethics assessment, user registration, content audit, data and personal information protection, fraud prevention, security monitoring, and incident response.
第七条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must publicly disclose the rules governing their recommendation services.
第七条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must have professional personnel and technical support proportionate to the scale of their algorithm recommendation services.
第七条
第八条 2 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must regularly audit, evaluate, and verify their algorithms, models, data, and results.
第八条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not deploy algorithms that induce user addiction, excessive consumption, or behavior that violates laws, regulations, or ethical standards.
第八条
第九条 4 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must strengthen information security management and build a feature library to identify illegal and harmful content with clear standards and procedures.
第九条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must label machine-generated synthetic information with prominent marking before distributing it.
第九条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must immediately stop transmitting illegal information, take removal measures, prevent its spread, keep records and report to internet and relevant authorities.
第九条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must handle harmful information according to network information content governance regulations.
第九条
第十条 2 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must strengthen management of user profiles and tags with clear rules for recording user interests and managing user tags.
第十条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not record keywords related to illegal or harmful content as user interests or tags for content distribution.
第十条
第十一条 3 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must strengthen management of platform layout and presentation ecology for algorithmic recommendation services.
第十一条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must establish and improve human intervention and user choice mechanisms in their services.
第十一条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must actively display information aligned with mainstream values at key locations such as homepages, trending sections, curated selections, rankings and pop-ups.
第十一条
第十二条 2 controls
- Applies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers are encouraged to use content deduplication and distribution strategies to reduce harm and prevent disputes.
第十二条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers should improve the transparency and explainability of their filtering, ranking, selection, distribution and presentation rules.
第十二条
第十三条 3 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers offering news information services through algorithm recommendations must obtain proper authorization and follow legal standards for news collection, editing, publication and distribution.
第十三条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not generate or synthesize false news information.
第十三条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not distribute news information from sources outside the scope authorized by national regulations.
第十三条
第十四条 4 controls
- ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use algorithms to falsely register accounts, conduct illegal account trading, or manipulate user accounts.
第十四条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use algorithms to artificially inflate engagement through false likes, comments or shares.
第十四条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use algorithms to suppress information, excessively promote content, manipulate rankings or search result ordering, or control trending topics.
第十四条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use algorithms to manipulate information presentation in ways that influence public opinion or circumvent regulatory oversight.
第十四条
第十五条 2 controls
- ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not use algorithms to unreasonably restrict other internet information service providers or obstruct their lawful operations.
第十五条 - ProhibitionApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must not engage in monopolistic or unfair competition practices through algorithmic means.
第十五条
第十六条 2 controls
- ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must clearly inform users in a prominent manner that they use algorithmic recommendation services.
第十六条 - ObligationApplies to: ProviderDrafted by the Index
Providers must publicly disclose the basic principles, purposes and main operational mechanisms of their recommendation algorithms.
第十六条
Change history
No changes recorded since we began monitoring this policy.