Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1001-11327
ConfirmedA court, a regulator or the organization itself has stated the core facts, or the record cites a court or regulator source.

US court upholds $243 million verdict against Tesla over fatal Autopilot crash

A US court upheld a $243 million jury verdict against Tesla over a 2019 Autopilot crash in Florida that killed a woman and injured her boyfriend. The court found Tesla 33% responsible, and the company has announced plans to appeal.

20 February 2026 Β· Tesla Β· Safety and wellbeing
20 February 2026
AII-1001-113277 sources ↓
Quick facts
Category
Safety and wellbeing
Country
United States
Source
CNBC
Date
20 February 2026
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

In 2019, a Model S driven by George McGee crashed into an SUV in Key Largo, Florida while McGee was distracted, killing a 22-year-old woman and severely injuring her boyfriend.

A jury found Tesla 33% responsible for the crash and awarded $243 million in damages. U.S. District Judge Beth Bloom refused to overturn the verdict on 20 February 2026.

Reported impact

The crash resulted in the death of a 22-year-old woman and severe injury to her boyfriend.

Index analysis

The case highlights ongoing concerns about Tesla's Autopilot safety and company accountability in autonomous vehicle crashes involving distracted drivers.

Governance controls

Tesla plans to appeal the decision, arguing the Model S was not defective and the company should not be liable for reckless driving by the vehicle's operator.

Classification

Category
Safety and wellbeing
Industry
Mobility and autonomous vehicles
Country
United States
Harm status
Actual harm
Intent
Unintentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Physical death, Physical injury, Human or fundamental rights
Harmed
Consumers, Women
Failure modes
Unsafe autonomous behaviour
Consequences
Litigation
AI systems
Autopilot

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

CNBC
Tesla loses bid to toss $243 million verdict in fatal Autopilot crash suit
20 February 2026
The Independent
Judge orders Tesla to pay $243 million over fatal Autopilot crash
20 February 2026
Reuters
US judge upholds $243 million verdict against Tesla over fatal Autopilot crash
20 February 2026
The Verge
Judge rejects Tesla's effort to overturn $243 million jury verdict.
20 February 2026
Devdiscourse
Tesla's Legal Setback: A $243 Million Jury Verdict | Law-Order
20 February 2026
Investing.com
Tesla's bid to overturn $243M autopilot crash verdict rejected By Investing.com
20 February 2026
Raw Story
Tesla suffers major court loss as judge upholds $243 million penalty in fatal crash
20 February 2026
Sep 2026US Lawmaker Presses NHTSA on Tesla Autopilot Misuse After Videos Show Sleeping DriversUnder investigationSafety and wellbeingReutersElectrekETAuto.comSep 2026US regulators probe Tesla Cybercabs for safety compliance one day after launchUnder investigationSafety and wellbeingtimesofindia.indiatimes.comThe Boston GlobeSep 2026Tesla driver cited for sleeping at wheel using Full Self-Driving on California highwayConfirmedSafety and wellbeingNew York PostSan Jose Mercury NewsSep 2026Tesla's Data Handling on Autopilot Safety Under EU Scrutiny Ahead of VoteAllegedSafety and wellbeingEl PeriΓ³dico de la EnergΓ­aQuotidiano di PugliaBusiness Insider+3Aug 2026Tesla driver falls asleep on Autopilot, police investigates in IsraelConfirmedSafety and wellbeingΧ’Χ¨Χ•Χ₯ Χ©Χ‘Χ’mako