Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-53003
Under investigationA regulator, court or police has opened a formal inquiry and reached no finding yet.

Three killed in India after GPS directions led car from incomplete bridge

Three men died when their car fell from an incomplete bridge in Uttar Pradesh after following outdated Google Maps directions that did not reflect flood damage to the structure. Police filed charges against four Public Works Department engineers and a Google Maps official for failing to update the navigation system or maintain safety measures at the damaged site.

24 November 2024 · Google Maps · Safety and wellbeing
24 November 2024
AII-1002-530032 sources ↓
Quick facts
Category
Safety and wellbeing
Country
India
Source
LatestLY
Date
24 November 2024
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

Three men—Nitin and Ajit, both 30 and brothers from Farrukhabad district, and Amit, 40, from Mainpuri district—were traveling from Noida to Faridpur in Bareilly to attend a wedding when their car fell into the Ramganga River from a partially constructed bridge on the Khalpur-Dataganj road around 10 am on November 24, 2024.

The driver was using Google Maps for navigation and did not realize the bridge was unsafe, having been damaged by earlier floods that year. Circle Officer Ashutosh Shivam stated that the flood damage had not been updated in the navigation system, and the approach to the damaged bridge had no safety barriers or warning signs.

Reported impact

Three people died in the accident. Police teams recovered the vehicle and bodies from the river, and the bodies were sent for post-mortem.

Governance controls

Police filed an FIR under section 105 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder) of the BNS against four engineers of the PWD—2 Assistant Engineers and 2 Junior Engineers—and unknown persons. The regional officer of Google Maps was brought under the scope of investigation but had not been named in the FIR at the time of reporting.

Budaun District Magistrate Nidhi Srivastava issued instructions to the PWD and Setu Nigam to inspect all roads, bridges, flyovers, and underpasses to prevent a repeat of such incidents. A Google spokesperson stated the company was working closely with authorities and providing support to investigate the issue.

Classification

Category
Safety and wellbeing
Industry
Mobility and autonomous vehicles
Country
India
Harm status
Actual harm
Intent
Unintentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Physical death, Physical injury, Human or fundamental rights
Harmed
General public
Failure modes
Unsafe recommendation
Consequences
Police investigation
AI systems
Google Maps

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

LatestLY
Badaun: Misled by GPS Navigation, Car Falls Into Ramganga River From Partially Constructed Bridge in Uttar Pradesh, 3 Dead (See Pic) | LatestLY
24 November 2024
economictimes.indiatimes.com
Three killed in India after GPS directions led car from incomplete bridge