Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-67157
ConfirmedA court, a regulator or the organization itself has stated the core facts, or the record cites a court or regulator source.

NHK ends AI multilingual subtitles after geopolitical terminology error

NHK's AI-powered multilingual subtitle service mistranslated "Senkaku Islands" (Okinawa) into Chinese as "Diaoyu Island" (the Chinese name) in a February 10 news broadcast on the Japan-US summit. The broadcaster ended the service on February 12, citing unreliable translation accuracy.

10 February 2025 · NHK · Reliability and hallucination
10 February 2025
AII-1002-671577 sources ↓
Quick facts
Category
Reliability and hallucination
Country
Japan
Source
毎日新聞
Date
10 February 2025
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

On February 10, NHK's international broadcast English news about the Japan-US summit was distributed on the internet with Chinese subtitles that partially displayed Okinawa's Senkaku Islands as 釣魚島 (Diaoyu Island, the Chinese name). Staff noticed the error.

The multilingual subtitle service had been using Google's AI automatic translation function since April 2020 to provide subtitles in nine languages including Chinese, Portuguese, and Ukrainian.

Reported impact

NHK announced on February 12 that it was ending the multilingual subtitle service, determining that the translation was unstable and unsuitable for NHK service.

Governance controls

NHK chairman Inaba Nobuo stated the company would accelerate development of NHK's own AI translation and generative AI systems.

Classification

Category
Reliability and hallucination
Industry
Media, social platforms and marketing
Country
Japan
Harm status
Actual harm
Intent
Unintentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Reputational, Public interest
Harmed
General public
Consequences
System suspension or termination
AI systems
Google AI translation

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

毎日新聞
NHK 多言語字幕サービス終了へ 英語によるライブ配信の字幕にミス「尖閣諸島」を「釣魚島」と表記
12 February 2025
Yahoo!ニュース
NHK国際放送ネット配信、AI自動翻訳で尖閣諸島を釣魚島と表示(朝日新聞)
12 February 2025
朝日新聞デジタル
NHK国際放送ネット配信、AI自動翻訳で尖閣諸島を釣魚島と表示:朝日新聞デジタル
12 February 2025
時事ドットコム
NHK、AIの多言語字幕サービス終了 尖閣諸島を中国名で表示のため:時事ドットコム
12 February 2025
日本経済新聞
NHK、AI翻訳の多言語字幕を終了 尖閣を中国名で表示
12 February 2025
産経ニュース
尖閣諸島を「釣魚島」と表示 NHK国際放送の中国語字幕 AI使用サービスとりやめ
12 February 2025
読売新聞オンライン
NHKがネット配信ニュースでAI翻訳ミス...「尖閣諸島」を「釣魚島」と表示、多言語字幕サービス終了
12 February 2025