Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-44761
ConfirmedA court, a regulator or the organization itself has stated the core facts, or the record cites a court or regulator source.

Meta scrapes Australian users' data for AI training without opt-out option

Meta admitted to scraping public Facebook and Instagram posts and photos from all Australian adult users since 2007 to train AI systems, without providing an opt-out option unlike European users. The disclosure emerged during parliamentary testimony about Meta's AI deployment practices in Australia.

10 September 2024 ยท Meta ยท Privacy and surveillance
10 September 2024
AII-1002-447615 sources โ†“
Quick facts
Category
Privacy and surveillance
Country
Australia
Source
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Date
10 September 2024
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

Meta has been scraping public Facebook and Instagram photos and posts from Australian users to train artificial intelligence. The scraping applies to all public posts made by Australian users aged over 18 since 2007, according to testimony by Meta's director of privacy policy Melinda Claybaugh to an Australian parliamentary committee.

Reported impact

Australian users do not have an option to opt out of the mass-scraping of their content, unlike European users who were given an opt-out option in response to General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) concerns. Millions of Australians who used Facebook and Instagram have not consented to having their photos, videos, and public post history used to train AI.

Index analysis

Meta paused the launch of its AI product in Europe in July due to GDPR privacy rules and provided European users with an opt-out option. Meta's director of privacy policy stated that the opt-out option in Europe was 'in response to a very specific legal frame' and did not commit to extending such an option to Australian users.

Governance controls

Australian users can set their posts to private prospectively to prevent future scraping, but this does not account for the scraping that has already occurred since 2007. Meta's approach differs from its treatment of European users, who received regulatory guidance on data use for AI training.

Classification

Category
Privacy and surveillance
Industry
Media, social platforms and marketing
Country
Australia
Harm status
Actual harm
Intent
Intentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Human or fundamental rights
Harmed
Consumers
Failure modes
Unauthorised scraping, Training data misuse
Consequences
None recorded
AI systems
Meta AI training system
Regulations
GDPR (cited)

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Facebook admits to scraping every Australian adult user's public photos and posts to train AI, with no opt out option
10 September 2024
News.com.au
Tech giant's bombshell admission
10 September 2024
Yahoo! Finance
Meta's AI is scraping users' photos and posts. Europeans can opt out, but Australians cannot
11 September 2024
Anadolu Ajansโ”€โ–’
Facebook admits scraping Australian user data for AI without opt-out option
11 September 2024
Daily Mail Online
Privacy law calls as Meta admits farming Aussie photos
11 September 2024