Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-49363
AllegedThe record is a lawsuit, complaint or accusation that has not been decided.

Former OpenAI researcher alleges company violated copyright law in AI training

Former OpenAI researcher Suchir Balaji has alleged that OpenAI violated copyright law by using copyrighted data without permission to train ChatGPT. Balaji left the company in August 2024 and claims the technology damages the internet, joining other individuals and organizations that have sued AI companies over unlicensed use of copyrighted material.

August 2024 ยท OpenAI ยท Intellectual property and appropriation
August 2024
AII-1002-493633 sources โ†“
Quick facts
Category
Intellectual property and appropriation
Country
United States
Source
Gizmodo
Date
August 2024
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

Suchir Balaji, a former AI researcher at OpenAI, spent nearly four years at the company helping gather and organize internet data used to build ChatGPT. After the chatbot's release in late 2022, he concluded that OpenAI's use of copyrighted data violated the law and that the technology was damaging the internet.

In August 2024, Balaji left OpenAI, stating he no longer wanted to contribute to technologies he believed would cause societal harm. He is among the first employees to leave a major AI company and speak out publicly against the use of copyrighted data in AI training.

Reported impact

Balaji believes the technologies like ChatGPT are damaging the internet, though the facts do not specify particular harms beyond this characterization.

Index analysis

Over the past two years, a number of individuals and businesses have sued various AI companies, including OpenAI, arguing they illegally used copyrighted material to train their technologies. Those who have filed suits include computer programmers, artists, record labels, book authors and news organizations.

In December 2023, The New York Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft, claiming they used millions of articles to build chatbots that compete with the news outlet. Both companies denied the claims.

Classification

Category
Intellectual property and appropriation
Industry
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Country
United States
Harm status
Potential harm
Intent
Unknown
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Economic or property
Harmed
Business
Failure modes
Training data misuse
Consequences
Litigation
AI systems
ChatGPT

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

Gizmodo
Former OpenAI Staffer Says the Company Is Breaking Copyright Law and Destroying the Internet
23 October 2024
Economic Times
Former OpenAI researcher says the company broke copyright law
24 October 2024
MoneyControl
Former OpenAI employee accuses company of 'destroying' the internet
24 October 2024
Oct 2026Carlsen Verlag sues OpenAI for copyright infringement of "Das NEINhorn"AllegedIntellectual property and appropriationSpiegel OnlineRP OnlineBรถrsenblatt+5Oct 2026Argentine media group Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft over unauthorized content useAllegedIntellectual property and appropriationPerfilClarinSep 2026Mathematician Accuses OpenAI of Using Unpublished Research in Model TrainingAllegedIntellectual property and appropriationThe VergeCybernewsQuartz+2Sep 2026OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra shows academic integrity concerns in mathematics researchAllegedIntellectual property and appropriationฤแปc bรกo tin tแปฉc, tin mแป›i Ngร y nay OnlineVietnamPlusAug 2026AI companies buy and destroy rare books for model trainingAllegedIntellectual property and appropriationThe Wall Street JournalOman Observer