Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-56243
ReportedReported by fewer than three independent publishers, with no official finding.

ChatGPT search tool vulnerable to manipulation via hidden text

The Guardian investigation found ChatGPT's search tool vulnerable to manipulation through hidden text in webpages, which can contain prompt injection instructions or content designed to influence its responses. Security researchers demonstrated the tool could return malicious code and misleading assessments of products despite negative information present on the same page.

24 December 2024 Β· OpenAI Β· Security and cyberattacks
24 December 2024
AII-1002-56243View source β†—
Quick facts
Category
Security and cyberattacks
Country
United Kingdom
Source
The Guardian
Date
24 December 2024
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

The Guardian investigation tested ChatGPT's search tool and found it vulnerable to manipulation through hidden content embedded in webpages.

Hidden content can contain prompt injection instructions that alter ChatGPT's responses, or large amounts of hidden text designed to influence its assessment of products or services.

A security researcher found that ChatGPT can return malicious code from websites it searches. Testing with a fake camera product page showed ChatGPT could be made to return positive assessments despite negative reviews on the same page.

Reported impact

The potential security issues could be exploited maliciously to cause ChatGPT to return false positive assessments of products despite negative information being present on the same webpage.

Index analysis

The vulnerability stems from ChatGPT's inability to distinguish between visible and hidden content when summarizing webpages, and its susceptibility to prompt injection attacks embedded in webpage text.

Classification

Category
Security and cyberattacks
Industry
Media, social platforms and marketing
Country
United Kingdom
Harm status
Potential harm
Intent
Unintentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Economic or property, Public interest
Harmed
Consumers, General public
Failure modes
Prompt injection, Manipulation or dark pattern, Agent misaction
Consequences
None recorded
AI systems
ChatGPT search tool

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

The Guardian
ChatGPT search tool vulnerable to manipulation and deception, tests show
24 December 2024