Alabama attorney fined for submitting AI-generated fake legal citations
An Alabama attorney was publicly reprimanded and fined $5,000 by a federal judge for submitting fabricated legal citations generated by ChatGPT-powered software in a criminal case filing. The attorney's client requested replacement counsel after learning of the incident, and the court ordered the attorney to file the reprimand in all pending and future cases for one year.
What happened
James A. Johnson, an attorney from Loxley, Alabama, submitted a motion in a federal criminal case in July 2025 that contained nonexistent legal citations generated by the Ghostwriter Legal plug-in, a Microsoft Word tool powered by ChatGPT.
The fabricated citations were discovered by opposing counsel from the US Attorney's Office. One citation referenced caselaw that had been reversed by the US Supreme Court over 40 years prior. Johnson stated he used the tool to draft the motion while providing post-surgery care for an out-of-state family member before the July 4 holiday weekend and failed to verify the citations before submission.
Reported impact
Johnson's client, the criminal defendant Johnson was appointed to defend, expressed shock and dismay at the hearing and requested new counsel. Johnson's false citations delayed the defendant's right to prompt adjudication and resulted in additional public funds being spent to appoint new defense counsel.
Index analysis
Judge Terry F. Moorer of the US District Court for the Southern District of Alabama stated on October 10, 2025 that the incident represents part of an 'epidemic of citing fake cases' in federal litigation despite media coverage, bar association training, and prior court sanctions against other attorneys for similar misconduct.
Moorer characterized Johnson's conduct as 'more than mere negligence or simple recklessness' and a failure to discharge basic lawyer responsibilities, noting that basic reprimands and small fines have not deterred similar misconduct by other attorneys.
Governance controls
The court imposed $5,000 in sanctions against Johnson and ordered him to file the court's reprimand order in any pending case where he appeared as counsel and in any future cases for the next 12 months. The judge referred the matter to a panel to determine whether Johnson should remain eligible to receive court-appointed criminal cases.
Classification
Sources and evidence
Sources not yet published
This record was researched and written by the Index from original reporting. Its sources are still being verified by an editor, and they are listed here once that check is complete. Until then the record carries no reviewer.