Skip to content
Submit incident
AII-1002-61459
Well documentedThree or more independent publishers report the core facts.

AI vocal clone of deceased French voice actor used without full consent

AI companies used a vocal clone of deceased French voice actor Alain Dorval to dub the film "Armor" without obtaining clear consent from his family. Aurore Bergé, Dorval's daughter, stated she had only approved a trial and that a final agreement guaranteed her and her mother would approve any use before publication.

10 January 2025 · ElevenLabs · Intellectual property and appropriation
10 January 2025
AII-1002-614598 sources ↓
Quick facts
Category
Intellectual property and appropriation
Country
France
Source
Paris Match
Date
10 January 2025
Drafted by
Raidu Incident Detection

What happened

Startups Lumiere Ventures and ElevenLabs used artificial intelligence to recreate the French voice of Sylvester Stallone's former voice actor, Alain Dorval, who died the previous year, for the action film Armor.

Aurore Bergé, Dorval's daughter and a French minister, stated she had agreed only to a trial and that an agreement guaranteed she and her mother would validate any use before publication. She posted on X that she discovered the trailer distributed on social media without her final approval, stating 'I never validated such a broadcast.'

Reported impact

The trailer sparked criticism on social networks, with some describing the result as caricatural and contestable.

Voice dubbing professionals expressed concern about the use of these new technologies, viewing the case as highlighting the threat AI poses to their profession.

Index analysis

The incident raises questions about consent and the use of a deceased person's voice without clear authorization from family members who hold rights to their likeness.

Classification

Category
Intellectual property and appropriation
Industry
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Country
France
Harm status
Actual harm
Intent
Unintentional
Timing
Post-deployment
Harm types
Reputational
Failure modes
Voice clone
AI systems
Armor vocal clone system

Sources and evidence

This record was researched and written by the Index, based on the following original reporting.

Paris Match
Voix française de Sylvester Stallone qui reprend celle d'Alain Dorval décédé : Aurore Bergé évoque un essai
11 January 2025
Télérama
Sylvester Stallone doublé par l'IA pour Amazon Prime? Les fans KO debout
11 January 2025
TF1 INFO
La voix de son père, doubleur de Stallone, recrée par l'IA ? Aurore Bergé dément avoir validé la bande-annonce | TF1 INFO
11 January 2025
Le Huffington Post
Comment la voix française de Stallone restera la même malgré la mort de son doubleur
12 January 2025
20minutes
La voix du doubleur français (décédé) de Stallone sera recréée par une IA
13 January 2025
BFMTV
La voix française de Sylvester Stallone recréée par IA? Aurore Bergé dément avoir donné son accord
13 January 2025
Femme Actuelle
La voix du père d'Aurore Bergé, doubleur de Sylvester Stallone, générée par IA dans un film : "J'ai donné mon accord pour un essai", précise la ministre
13 January 2025
Les Numériques
Prime Video utilise l'IA pour doubler Sylvester Stallone et le résultat ne passe pas
13 January 2025